Beneath the lyrics, certain songs tell another story about the culture, politics, and beliefs of their time.

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Psychology’s Nature vs. Nurture debate

Song Sociology – Beneath The Lyrics

Let it go – Luba Kowalchyk
Secrets and Sins – 1984

Lyrics:

Too many doubts
Too much fear
Too much danger
When society constructs our human nature
Live by the rules
Live by the laws
Live by commandments
Notions preconceived can lead to utter madness
Let it go
Let it go
Let it free your body
Let it move your soul
Let it go, oh no
We are made, we are not born
Let it go
Let it free your body
Let it move your soul
Let it go, oh no
We are made, we are not born
Learn to convert
Learn to assert
Learn to abandon
Ideologies and disciplines at random
Lay down my laws
Lay down the rules
Lay down commandments
Lift the sanctions
That restrict this woman's madness (repeat chorus)
Uniformity

Conventionality
Is the bane of our existence
Keep it safely at a distance
Nonconformity
Unconventionality
Is too good to be
Let your hair down
Can't you see
Let it go

Let it go
Let it free your body
Let it move your soul
Let it go, oh no
We are made, we are not born
Let it go
Let it free your body
Let it move your soul
Let it go, oh no
A woman is made, she is not born
Let it go
Let it free your head
Uncivilize your soul
Oh, oh
Let it go
Let it free your head
Uncivilize your soul
Let it go
Oh, let it go
Let it free your head
Uncivilize your soul


Cresting in the 1980’s, this song conveys one extreme of the pendulum swing in Psychology’s Nature vs. Nurture debate.

Simply put, the debate argues to what degree a person’s psychological traits or personality is determined by their genetics (nature) or their socialization, upbringing (nurture). Although it is accepted that the truth is a combination of these factors create our traits, abilities, and potential. However, at times, both nature and nurture have overshadowed the other in the degree to which we believed in their influence.

One extreme in the debate is genetic determinism. That everything we are comes directly from our genes. From the beginnings of psychology the idea of genetic determinism has been used as an excuse for oppression and tyranny against various groups based on complete fabrications, internalized biases, and just plain bad science. The lie of white racial superiority and racial, ethnic and sex differences assumed and created were used to justify oppression and even violence throughout recent history, from European imperialism, to slavery. The most infamous use of this bad science as propaganda was by the Nazi’s to justify their crimes against humanity during WWII. The horrors of the holocaust began a backlash against genetic determinism that continued most notably with the fight for equality by minorities and women in the 1960’s and 70’s.
The idea of discussing a person’s potential or character traits based on their genetics became very controversial as the biased science of genetic determinism was brought to light.
American IQ tests are a notable example. The revision to Alfred Binet’s benign Simon-Binet intelligence test, is known as the Stanford-Binet, and was put forth as a tool to judge fixed intelligence levels, something Alfred Binet clearly dismissed in his original work. None the less, Lewis M. Terman, who created the Stanford-Binet, and others used new tests to judge racial differences in intelligence based on tests tailor-made for educated, English speakers. When administered to immigrants with varying level of English comprehension and minorities long denied adequate education, much was made of the unsurprising results. As for sex difference, the story is quite illuminating as to the credibility of the testing, and the impartiality of the creators. In the 30’s and 40’s, frustrated at the consistently superior results of girls over boys, these ‘impartial’ scientists realized that they must alter the test content until the appropriate and reverse result was achieved. The debate raged on into the 70’s and mainstream opinion turned against the science of sex and race. So, for a time, discussion of genetics, even of interplay of genetics and socialization, was effectively silenced. Whatever objective science had been done was largely discredited by the overwhelming damage that genetic determinism caused to minority ethnic groups and women.
As well, the rise in popularity of all types of talk-based psychotherapy and group therapy turned our focus to our personal histories, and furthered the belief that our upbringing was the cause of our personal problems and character traits, thus creating our potential. There was great hope that people could change for the better just as society was changing at this time. The purpose of most talk therapy is to work through our past issues by acknowledging their causes, which were most often thought to be childhood traumas. The success of this therapy rests on the belief that our upbringing or how we were socialized (nurture) can be overcome. So a belief in genetics (nature), as it was generally understood at the time, would not be good for business and was contrary to our notions of positive change. People simply didn’t want to hear that aspects of our character may have been contributed by our genes before birth, as this was interpreted to mean that these traits were essentially immutable. In the 1980’s talk therapy became Talk shows, taking this belief and business to another level in our consciousness. By the early 1980’s, we could watch a stranger share their personal demons, and seemingly make progress in overcoming them, from the comfort of our homes on the numerous talk shows of the time. Theories of genetics were seldom heard in the mainstream media, and generally only as cautionary tales of oppression. The pendulum had reached its apex in the 80’s, and the general belief was that nurture ruled over nature in creating our character and potential, and then, inevitably, the pendulum began its descent and the return of genetics as a major field of study and a viable field of research began. Some groundbreaking and valuable research has been done, although the bad science of genetic determinism’s past always reappears, as do our biases and stereotypes. Hopefully we can retain a healthy skepticism as that pendulum continues its swing to the other extreme.

Luba sings, “We are made, we are not born.” Obviously supporting the prevailing belief of the 1980’s favouring nurture over nature. She goes on to say, “When society constructs our human nature.” That we should and can, “Let it go.” This song speaks directly to women. She says that laws, rules, and commandments are, “Notions preconceived,” which, “can lead to utter madness”, so we must lay them down to be free of what, “… restrict this woman's madness.” Luba’s refrain to, “let it go,” this time is because, “a woman is made, she is not born.” She is clearly arguing that our potential as women is shaped and stunted by the laws and rules of society and religion, and not by any genetic legacy. So, if we can only let go of the teachings ingrained in us, then who knows what woman could achieve. This was a common Feminist belief at that time and even with the new research into the genetics of sex, and gender roles, “Let it go.” remains good advice regardless of where that pendulum is heading.

This is a great song, and one thing I love about it is how she puts such a weighty topic into a 4-4 beat dance song. It was on the pop charts in Canada for 40 weeks and reached the number 1 position on a number of them.

Also, interesting is Luba criticism of “uniformity and conventiality”, which is justified especially in the context of the time, but hindsight being 20/20, or clearer at any rate, we can see how much her opinion is a product of its time. It is, I think, a reminder to us of how our points of view are limited by the parameters of our knowledge at any given period. Certainly we must move forward and express ourselves, but the ability to adapt our belief system or even, forgive me, to “let it go,” is essential.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NK3L6ccMQ4U

7 comments:

  1. Interesting stuff! Oh Luba, I knew you would one day teach us something!
    I used to totally believe in the idea of nurture in gender traits and thought that boys and girls were made into boys and girls only by society. Once I had Matteo, I had to change my mind somewhat. He does these typical "boy" things out of the blue and I don't know where he learned them (before daycare) He one day when he was really small, picked up a car and said "vroooom" and only wants to play with cars and trains. I really want him to play with dolls, but I can't see it happening.

    ReplyDelete
  2. For an interesting discussion on nature vs nurture in gender studies, the book "As Nature Made Him: The Boy Who Was Raised As A Girl" is essential reading. It's the story of David Reimer and his twin brother. Due to a botched circumcision, they tried raising David as a girl. This 'twin' study was used as the basis for "proving" gender behaviours were learned. David gave permission for this book to be written to counter that study.

    http://www.amazon.ca/As-Nature-Made-Him-Raised/dp/0060192119

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ι am actually thankful to the holder of thiѕ site who has shared this great post at hеre.


    my homepаgе www.rukajgallery.net
    My site - decorating ideas for bathrooms

    ReplyDelete
  4. This excеllent wеbѕite certainly haѕ all the infοrmаtion I needed
    about this subjeсt and didn't know who to ask.

    my blog; moon phase calendar
    Here is my web-site ; priceline commercial 2012

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thеre is definately a lot to find out about this iѕsue.
    I lоve all the ρoints you've made.

    Have a look at my web blog: Mariopartyforum.Com
    Feel free to surf my blog post ... real estate calculator

    ReplyDelete
  6. each tіme i used to read smaller сontent ωhich as wеll clеar their mоtive, anԁ thаt is also haρρening with
    this piece of writing which I am reading at this time.


    Revіew mу weblog vapornine
    My web page - vapornine

    ReplyDelete
  7. I love what you guуs аre usually up too.
    This kind of clever ωork and exρosure! Кeep up the awesome works
    guyѕ I've incorporated you guys to blogroll.

    Here is my web site ... wbf
    Also visit my site axr

    ReplyDelete